A Cat Has No Use for the Alphabet — THE CONUNDRUMS QUOTATIONS PROJECT — CQ-050

CQ-050: “I’m envious of his freedom.” A man watches a black cat walk away across a prison yard.

“I’m envious of his freedom.”

— Easy Waters, “Doing Hard Time,” Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice

Erebus comes up to the man in the yard and rubs against his leg. The man bends down to stroke him. He has nothing for Erebus to eat, and the cat is off. There’s no great drama in this. If you’ve ever known a cat, you know he doesn’t owe you a goodbye.

What he can do, and what the man can’t do in “Doing Hard Time,” is keep going.

It’s Labor Day. The law library is open. So is the rear yard, which is usually closed except on special occasions. There are baseball fields, horseshoe pits and cows with numbers in their ears. There’s even a crab race. Men get down on their hands and feet for a chance to win a soda. (What some guys will do for a Coke.) Erebus comes back and stands between the narrator’s legs to watch. Then he takes off again.

I gave the cat a name that belongs to darkness, and there he is in broad daylight, running after leaves with the other cats. There’s only one tree in the yard. The wind has the whole field. The narrator decides to walk a few laps, and the path the men are allowed to take is shaped like a T. The cat has no use for the alphabet.

This prison has no security fence around its perimeter. I wanted the reader to know that before the narrator looks out across the field and sees the gray sky meet the grass. It looks to him like a wall. He knows what a wall in a maximum security prison looks like. He supplies the wall himself, from memory. Still, the rule about where he can walk is real. He doesn’t have to see a fence to know where he’s supposed to turn.

I could have written about a man watching a bird fly over the yard. There’s something more aggravating about this cat. Erebus has his feet on the same ground the narrator does. He goes where he pleases for reasons of his own, including the entirely respectable reason that somebody else might have something to eat. What the narrator envies is a little thing: the distance between deciding to go and going.

What ordinary choice would you miss first if someone else decided where you could walk?

The Conundrums Quotations Project revisits lines from Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice, one quotation at a time.

Justice, Literature & Memory — Delivered to Your Inbox

Essays from the archive and new writing on race, literature, history, incarceration, freedom, and the American criminal legal system.


Discover more from William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

About William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

William Eric Waters is an award-winning poet, fiction writer, essayist, educator, criminal-justice scholar, and nonprofit executive. Writing as William E. Waters, he is the author of the epic poem Black Shadows and Through the White Looking Glass and three poetry collections: Sometimes Blue Knights Wear Black Hats, The Black Feminine Mystique, and The Black Blood of Poetry. Under the pen name Easy Waters, he is the author of the novel Streets of Rage and the short-story collection Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice. His work explores Black history, race, law, punishment, institutional power, accountability, redemption, and resilience.
This entry was posted in Literature & Cultural Criticism and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply