The Water Still Needs an Answer — THE CONUNDRUMS QUOTATIONS PROJECT — CQ-051

CQ-051: “Make the cloudy water we drink clear.” A glass of cloudy water sits on a ledge in a dark hallway.

“Make the cloudy water we drink clear.”

Easy Waters, “Ecce Homo!,” Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice

Angelmiguel asks a correction officer if he believes in God. Delacroix tells him he is God. Angelmiguel laughs. The officer wants to know what’s so funny.

So Angelmiguel asks for proof. Walk on water. Turn water to wine. Then comes a request for something the men in this prison would have use for: clear water to drink.

The third request is the one I keep coming back to. The first two belong to stories Angelmiguel knows from Scripture. The third belongs to the place where he has to live. He says we drink. He could have asked for a private miracle, something he alone would see and know. He asks for something the other men would notice the next time they took a drink.

Delacroix doesn’t have to answer. He tells Angelmiguel to step off. When Angelmiguel stands there, the officer repeats the command and calls it a direct order. It’s a small piece of dialogue, but listen to how much work that word direct does. A moment ago the officer was boasting about creating the heavens and the earth. Now he can end the conversation by telling a man where he can stand.

I don’t take Angelmiguel’s question as proof that he has the moral upper hand for the rest of the story. He leaves the corridor, and what he does later in the church makes the scene harder to read. A man who has just challenged somebody for making a sport of his authority will soon put his hands on that man and write a judgment of his own across his chest. Angelmiguel is sure God will help him. Delacroix, too, sounded sure.

I wanted the water to stay in the reader’s mind after that confrontation. It would be easy to remember who claimed to speak for God and forget what the man in the corridor said about the water he had to drink. The officer gets the last word in the hallway. The water still needs an answer.

Join the Conversation

When someone in prison raises a concern about the water they drink, what would count as a satisfactory answer?

About the Conundrums Quotations Project

CQ-051 revisits a line from “Ecce Homo!” in Easy Waters’s Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice.

Justice, Literature & Memory — Delivered to Your Inbox

Essays from the archive and new writing on race, literature, history, incarceration, freedom, and the American criminal legal system.


Discover more from William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

About William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

William Eric Waters is an award-winning poet, fiction writer, essayist, educator, criminal-justice scholar, and nonprofit executive. Writing as William E. Waters, he is the author of the epic poem Black Shadows and Through the White Looking Glass and three poetry collections: Sometimes Blue Knights Wear Black Hats, The Black Feminine Mystique, and The Black Blood of Poetry. Under the pen name Easy Waters, he is the author of the novel Streets of Rage and the short-story collection Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice. His work explores Black history, race, law, punishment, institutional power, accountability, redemption, and resilience.
This entry was posted in Literature & Cultural Criticism and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply