A Jury of His Peers Puts Bigger Thomas on Trial

Teaching Richard Wright’s Native Son in Prison

Richard Wright’s seminal work, Native Son, first published in 1940, remains as provocative today as it was then.

As a professor of African American Literature, in the course African American Literature in the 20th Century, students are tasked with writing their final paper on Native Son. Throughout the semester, we discuss Native Son after students have read W.E.B. DuBois’ “Criteria of Negro Art,” Alain Locke’s “The New Negro,” Langston Hughes’ “The Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain,” Richard Wright’s “Blueprint for Negro Writing,” Ralph Ellison’s “Richard Wright’s Blues,” James Baldwin’s “Everybody’s Protest Novel,” and even George Samuel Schuyler’s “The Negro-Art Hokum.” I instruct the students to be in conversation with the authors, to interrogate the texts, and to develop a lens in which to look at the literature we will be engaging throughout the semester. By the end of the course, I hope I have articulated Black Aesthetics (Black Poetics) in a manner that students have not only developed a deeper appreciation of “Black literature” but also developed a critical and scholarly lens from which they will view all literature.

For the past three years, I have taught African American Literature in the 20th Century at maximum and medium security prisons in New York State. This semester, for the first time, in discussing Native Son, one student stated that he was rooting for Bigger Thomas, the main character in Wright’s novel, during his “flight,” after he has committed two homicides, one unintentional, the killing of Mary Dalton, a young white female, and the attempted cover up of his crime, and the other one intentional, the killing of Bessie, his Black girlfriend, whom Bigger had confessed to the killing of Mary because he thought that she might give him up or be a witness against him. Before killing her, Bigger has sex with Bessie, and the students debate whether or not the sexual act is rape. Afterwards, Bigger throws Bessie down an elevator shaft in an abandoned tenement building, leaving her for dead.

Most of my classes in prison are populated by men of color, although I have taught African American Literature in a medium security women’s prison, where the students were primarily white; they were phenomenally engaged with the works, though I did not teach Native Son, but that is another story.

In my class populated mostly by men of color, I have asked this question:

Is there a Bigger in you?

Beyond rooting for Bigger, many students see and acknowledge a Bigger within themselves. One student reported that looking at Bigger’s crimes brought shame into his consciousness for the crimes he had committed in his community. Perhaps I reassure the students when I tell them that both James Baldwin and Frantz Fanon wrote that “there’s a Bigger in all of us” (men of color).

Native Son is often categorized as a “protest novel,” but it is much more. Primarily, it is a tale of crime and punishment. And Bigger is not the only “criminal” in the tale. Unlike Dostoevsky’s main character, Raskolnikov, in Crime and Punishment, though Wright takes us into Bigger’s mind as Dostoevsky did with Raskolnikov, Bigger doesn’t experience guilt or remorse. Neither does Bigger justify his crimes. They cannot be justified. In a court of law, we often theorize about motive, which is actually secondary to prosecutors proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, but there is truly no motive in Bigger’s crimes. But in the end, there is a revelation: the fear that has permeated the very existence of Bigger’s life is no more. Although he has become a murderer, he has also become a man.


Discover more from William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

About William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

William Eric Waters is an award-winning poet, fiction writer, essayist, educator, criminal-justice scholar, and nonprofit executive. Writing as William E. Waters, he is the author of the epic poem Black Shadows and Through the White Looking Glass and three poetry collections: Sometimes Blue Knights Wear Black Hats, The Black Feminine Mystique, and The Black Blood of Poetry. Under the pen name Easy Waters, he is the author of the novel Streets of Rage and the short-story collection Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice. His work explores Black history, race, law, punishment, institutional power, accountability, redemption, and resilience.
This entry was posted in Education & Teaching and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply