Growing Old in Plain Sight: The Years a Sentence Cannot Show — THE CONUNDRUMS QUOTATIONS PROJECT — CQ-037

CQ-037: “I wonder what crimes have landed these old-timers in prison, or if they grew old in prison.” — Easy Waters, Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice.

“I wonder what crimes have landed these old-timers in prison, or if they grew old in prison.”

Easy Waters, “One Day in the Life of a Jailhouse Lawyer,” Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice

Can a person grow old in plain sight and still go unseen?

On his way to the law library in “One Day in the Life of a Jailhouse Lawyer,” E notices older men cleaning the prison corridors. One holds a cane in one hand and a duster in the other. The cane supports him. The duster keeps him at work.

That image could carry an entire argument.

But E begins with uncertainty. He does not know what brought these men to prison or how long they have been there. His observation moves from the offense to the years. He wonders whether they entered prison as older men or became older men inside it.

The difference is a life.

A sentence on paper makes time appear orderly. There is a date, a term, perhaps a minimum, perhaps a possibility of release. A body tells time differently. It records the years in the way a person walks, bends, stands, and reaches for support. The cane makes visible something the calendar cannot fully explain.

The corridor keeps functioning. Floors are cleaned. Windows are washed. People pass on their way to work or meals. Aging becomes part of the scenery unless someone stops long enough to see it. E stops in the only way available to him at that moment: he notices, and he carries the question into the story.

Later, an older man delivers the law journal. E’s attention returns to the body: the bowed head, the rounded shoulders, the movement of someone who has spent decades in prison. His sadness also contains recognition. He imagines himself years into the future.

To see another person clearly can be to glimpse what may happen to you.

These scenes complicate the distance between observer and observed. E is going to work on legal documents. The men in the corridor are doing their assigned tasks. Each has a history the others may not know. Each is living through time that the institution can count more easily than it can account for.

Recognizing age does not require us to pretend that harm never occurred. It requires us to consider what continued incarceration is meant to accomplish now, in the life of the person before us. That inquiry deserves more than an automatic return to the earliest entry in a file.

A meaningful review would have to consider the person’s present circumstances: health, mobility, relationships, conduct, growth, and the support available outside prison. It would have to ask how these circumstances bear on the reasons offered for continued confinement. The answers may be difficult. Difficulty is a reason to examine them carefully.

The literary scene offers no ready-made assessment instrument. Its contribution is attention. Before there can be an adequate review, there must be a willingness to recognize that the person being reviewed has lived through all the years the record lists.

For those who teach or provide services in prison, the cane and duster also raise immediate questions about daily life. An assignment that once seemed routine may become painful or exhausting. A familiar corridor may become an obstacle. Needs change while schedules remain the same.

Literature can interrupt that sameness. It can hold an image before us until we understand that a person’s life is occurring inside it.

The man has a cane in one hand and a duster in the other. The institution has counted his presence. E asks us to consider his years.

Join the Conversation

What should a meaningful review of continued incarceration consider when a person has grown old in prison?

About the Conundrums Quotations Project

CQ-037 explores a quotation from “One Day in the Life of a Jailhouse Lawyer,” in Easy Waters’s Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice. The project reads individual lines closely to examine the larger questions of law, justice, memory, and the human spirit they open.

Justice, Literature & Memory — Delivered to Your Inbox

Essays from the archive and new writing on race, literature, history, incarceration, freedom, and the American criminal legal system.


Discover more from William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

About William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

William Eric Waters is an award-winning poet, fiction writer, essayist, educator, criminal-justice scholar, and nonprofit executive. Writing as William E. Waters, he is the author of the epic poem Black Shadows and Through the White Looking Glass and three poetry collections: Sometimes Blue Knights Wear Black Hats, The Black Feminine Mystique, and The Black Blood of Poetry. Under the pen name Easy Waters, he is the author of the novel Streets of Rage and the short-story collection Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice. His work explores Black history, race, law, punishment, institutional power, accountability, redemption, and resilience.
This entry was posted in Literature & Cultural Criticism, The Conundrums Quotations Project and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply