
“One thing about the law: I’m always learning something new.”
Easy Waters, “One Day in the Life of a Jailhouse Lawyer,” Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice
What keeps curiosity alive when a person is tired of the life around it?
In “One Day in the Life of a Jailhouse Lawyer,” E returns to the law library after lunch. He does not feel like doing anything. He is tired of prison. Some days, he admits, he goes through the motions. Then his attention settles on a small pad on his desk. He has written down words he encountered in law review articles—words he wants to look up.
A few unfamiliar words. A small pad. An unfinished act of learning.
The detail is easy to pass over. The story has already carried us through legal work, disappointment, institutional routines, and the long labor of waiting. Yet here, in the middle of an afternoon E does not especially want to face, there is something he still wants to know.
His curiosity has survived the morning.
That survival should not become an excuse to overlook his exhaustion. The sentences belong together. He is weary of prison, and he continues to learn. Neither observation cancels the other. The story allows a person to be intellectually engaged without requiring him to be cheerful about the circumstances in which that engagement occurs.
Those of us who teach should sit with that distinction.
A student can arrive tired and still care deeply about the work. A quiet afternoon may conceal considerable effort. Someone who has been reading difficult material may need time to return to a sentence, identify an unfamiliar word, and discover what the writer means. The visible performance of enthusiasm tells us only so much.
E’s pad records an intention. He has encountered the limit of his knowledge and made a place for the question. He does not pretend to know the words. He writes them down.
There is an intellectual discipline in that modest act. Reading produces uncertainty; uncertainty becomes an inquiry; the inquiry waits on a desk until the reader can take it up again. Learning moves through the ordinary materials available to him.
The subject makes the scene more complicated. E is studying the law, the body of knowledge through which he challenges his confinement and helps others challenge theirs. Earlier in the story, the legal books seem to surround him with another kind of imprisonment. Now the same field offers something new to understand. His relationship to it includes frustration, necessity, criticism, and curiosity.
He can question the law’s operation while continuing to study its language. Indeed, close study may sharpen the criticism. Understanding an institution does not require agreeing with what it does.
This is one reason education in prison deserves room for more than a predetermined story of personal improvement. People read to pursue practical aims, to challenge arguments, to write, to enjoy themselves, and to satisfy an interest that belongs to them. An unfamiliar word may become useful in a legal filing. It may also matter simply because a reader refuses to leave it unexplored.
The scene asks something of the educator, too. If curiosity is present alongside fatigue, our task includes making it possible for the inquiry to continue. That may mean access to a dictionary, a readable copy of a text, an explanation offered without condescension, or enough time to work through a difficult passage.
High expectations can coexist with attention to circumstances. We can take a student’s intellectual capacity seriously while recognizing the conditions under which the work must be done. A person should not have to appear untouched by confinement to be recognized as a serious learner.
Nor should the learner’s persistence become an institutional alibi. E’s continuing curiosity tells us something about E. It does not settle the questions the story raises about his imprisonment or the treatment of people around him.
The small pad remains on the desk. The words await their definitions. E is tired, but the world has not exhausted his capacity to encounter something he does not yet know.
Sometimes the evidence of an intellectual life is that simple: a question someone intends to return to.
Join the Conversation
How can educators support learning when exhaustion makes participation difficult?
About the Conundrums Quotations Project
CQ-040 explores a quotation from “One Day in the Life of a Jailhouse Lawyer,” in Easy Waters’s Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice. The project reads individual lines closely to examine the larger questions of law, justice, memory, and the human spirit they open.
Justice, Literature & Memory — Delivered to Your Inbox
Essays from the archive and new writing on race, literature, history, incarceration, freedom, and the American criminal legal system.
Discover more from William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.