Read These Too: When Knowledge Becomes Mutual Support — THE CONUNDRUMS QUOTATIONS PROJECT — CQ-041

CQ-041: “Read these too.” Two men study legal books together in a prison law library. Easy Waters, Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice.

“Read these too.”

Easy Waters, “One Day in the Life of a Jailhouse Lawyer,” Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice

What does knowledge become when someone else needs it?

In “One Day in the Life of a Jailhouse Lawyer,” Walker is researching questions that may affect his sentence and parole eligibility. E listens, remembers a relevant case, and pulls a book from the shelf. He supplies references. Walker writes them down.

Then comes a complication. E explains that the decision did not resolve the particular issue Walker wants to raise. A promising case has a limit. Finding it is the beginning of the work.

E takes down three more books.

“Read these too.”

Three words. Several volumes. Another person’s future.

The exchange has none of the ceremony we associate with expertise. There is no introduction listing qualifications. No podium. No professional biography. There are two people in prison, a legal problem, and someone who knows where to look.

That knowledge has a history. E describes cases lodged in his memory, accumulated through years of reading and litigation. The language he uses elsewhere in this passage is painful: the cases have become part of him. What looks like ready access to information has been acquired through sustained work under conditions he did not choose.

Now the memory becomes useful to someone else.

The scene is especially revealing because E does not simply tell Walker what he wants to hear. He points out the weakness in relying on a particular decision. He distinguishes the issue Walker hopes to argue from what the court actually decided. Then he directs him toward further reading.

This is intellectual care in a practical form. It includes correction. Encouragement alone would leave Walker with an incomplete understanding. E’s help asks him to read more carefully and consider more material.

The person receiving assistance remains a participant. Walker brings his own questions, identifies the issue that concerns him, takes notes, and carries the books away. The exchange gives him work to do. It respects his capacity to do it.

For those of us who teach, mentor, or administer programs, there is much to recognize here. Learning often travels through conversations that never appear on a syllabus. Someone explains a word. Someone remembers a source. Someone says that an appealing interpretation will not survive a close reading.

Inside prison, these exchanges can become part of the infrastructure through which people understand institutions and act on their own behalf. A law library contains books. Its usefulness also depends on the people who can help others find, read, and question them.

We should recognize that labor without making it carry obligations that belong elsewhere. The skill of a jailhouse lawyer does not excuse inadequate legal assistance. The willingness of people to teach one another does not relieve an institution of responsibility for educational resources. Mutual support deserves support of its own.

Recognition should therefore have practical consequences. People doing this work need reliable materials, time to study, opportunities to deepen their knowledge, and room to explain what is missing. Their experience should inform decisions about the services supposedly designed for them.

The story also invites us to reconsider where we look for teachers. A person can possess knowledge worth learning from while living under a designation that encourages others to overlook it. Attention to the exchange reveals what the designation cannot: a practiced reader helping another reader reason through a consequential question.

E hands over the books. Walker thanks him. The afternoon continues.

No ruling has been changed in this scene. No release has been secured. Something necessary has nevertheless happened. A question has met an informed response, a limitation has been made clear, and the next stage of inquiry has become possible.

“Read these too.” Knowledge leaves the shelf and enters a relationship.

Join the Conversation

How should institutions recognize the expertise people develop while helping one another?

About the Conundrums Quotations Project

CQ-041 explores a quotation from “One Day in the Life of a Jailhouse Lawyer,” in Easy Waters’s Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice. The project reads individual lines closely to examine the larger questions of law, justice, memory, and the human spirit they open.

Justice, Literature & Memory — Delivered to Your Inbox

Essays from the archive and new writing on race, literature, history, incarceration, freedom, and the American criminal legal system.


Discover more from William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Unknown's avatar

About William Eric Waters, aka Easy Waters

William Eric Waters is an award-winning poet, fiction writer, essayist, educator, criminal-justice scholar, and nonprofit executive. Writing as William E. Waters, he is the author of the epic poem Black Shadows and Through the White Looking Glass and three poetry collections: Sometimes Blue Knights Wear Black Hats, The Black Feminine Mystique, and The Black Blood of Poetry. Under the pen name Easy Waters, he is the author of the novel Streets of Rage and the short-story collection Conundrums: Stories of Law & Justice. His work explores Black history, race, law, punishment, institutional power, accountability, redemption, and resilience.
This entry was posted in Literature & Cultural Criticism, The Conundrums Quotations Project and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply